Q.2 (c) "The early medieval India saw many transitions." Explain
Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024
The Early Medieval period in India is considered to be a transitory phase between Ancient and Medieval India and thus is a complex whole in itself with wide varying features.
Transitions from Ancient to Medieval Indian history has been many the brunt of which has been bore by Early Medieval Indian period. Major transitions =>
1. Economic Transition - Trade and commerce that flourished till Gupta period began to decline in Early medieval period. R.S. Sharma and D.D. Kosambi called it urban decay whereas others like Y.S. Subbarayalu and J. Deyell called it just a gradual decline and that too only in some areas. However, the earlier commerce had reduced
2. Agricultural transition - the lands earlier owned by ruler got disintegrated and segmented giving rise to the 'Feudalism' in India, says R.S. Shasma
However some historians like Subbarayalu called that only 20% of lands were feudalized. However most historians agree that there was an increase in lord vassal relationship due to decline in centralized polity.
3. Social Transition - The caste hierarchy, four fold varna system strengthened. The position of Vaisyas greatly reduced. Alberuni said that they were equal to Sudras and their tongue was cut on chanting vedas. The decline was due to decline in trade and commerce.
There was also a decline in the position of women. Sati became frequent. Religious orthodoxy increased. Subcastes came into vogue. Devadasi was common.
4. Cultural transition - Due to strengthening of caste system in Hinduism and also strengthening of hierarchy in Buddhism. Bhakti cult emerged attracting mass support.
5. Miscellaneous - Alberuni wrote that ancient Indian culture was rich. However their arrogance and self pride have made the people of Hindustan insular to western culture which is leading to their defeats in the hands of foreigners.
The Hindustanis have stopped growing and learning from the world and are engulfed in their own orthodoxy, superiority complex and superstition, points Alberuni.
The disintegration on the cultural, socio political and economic front brought about in early medieval India again got united under Delhi Sultanate with the beginning of Medieval India, points Muhammad Habib calling that rural and urban revolution.