Topper Copies

How does Al-Biruni describe the science and religious life of India? What were the limitations of his account?

Ashish Raghuwanshi

Al-Beruni was a Khwarizm traveller who wrote Kitab-ul-Hind in which he described science and religions life of India during 10th - 11th century.

Science

1) He describes Indian astronomers like Brahmagupta, Varahmihra and Arbhatya. 2) He mentions Hindus had knowledge of real cause behind Eclipses. 3) In Mathematics, he credits Hindus for decimals, discovery of zero and Mentions works of Arbhatya like ('Aryabhatiyam' in which he describes trignometry, 'pi' value, AP, GP, etc. 4.) He also mentions about Medical science knowledge of Indians (eg) vata, pita, kapha — in Ayurveda

Religious life of India

1.) He describes that masses follow polytheism while learned sections are monotheist.

2.) He discusses various aspects of Hindu philosophy (eg) swarg-narak, Moksha , Karma , etc.

3.) He describes role of Brahmins and various rituals in Temples.

4.) Description of Caste System and Untouchables and religious sanction behind these practices.

5.) He describes 'inward looking' Hindus as he says that 'Hindus thinks high of no culture but theirs, no king but theirs'. 6.) Mentions religious oral traditions and knowledge transmission by Brahmins whom he accuses of Monopoly.

Limitations of his account

1.) He wrote about India and different places without actually visiting them as he himself limited to North-West region. 2.) His observations are sourced from different local informants which are doubted of authenticity. 3.) Many aspects he covers are based on heresay and he learns from different secondary sources which themselves may be problematic. 4.) His description of religion and science based on reading of texts like Vedas, puranas, Smriti, etc of which dates are unclear. 5.) He gave a top-down perspective of Indian Society not perspective from below. therefore he do not grasp the village societies.

Nevertheless known as father of Indology, Alberuni is important Scholar whose work contributed immensly in historiography of India.