Topper Copies

Discuss the religious policy of Aurangzeb. How far did it contribute to the downfall of the Mughal empire?

Ashish Raghuwanshi

Aurangzeb's reign is shrouded in controversy particularly around his religious policy.

Various aspects of his religious policy

1.) Court ceremonies - Asher and Talbot writes that due to his allegiance to orthodox Islam he stopped practices like Tuladan, Jharoka Darshan, wearing gold in garments, etc

2.) [Diwali and Holi] His instruction to Gujarat Governor that Holi and Diwali not to be celebrated in bazaars of Ahmedabad and pargana. However, no general ban in his empire.

3.) [Jaziya] He reimposed Jaziya on Hindus in 1679. Z. Faruqi -> This was done due to financial needs. Jadunath Sarkar -> His plan to establish dar-ul-Islam. S.R. Sharma -> His plan for Islamization as poor Hindus would be forced to convert. Satish chandra -> action taken to appease orthodox ulema

4.) [Temples] His order of destroying Taza danamkhanas (new temples) and prohibition on repair of old temples. He destroyed temples like Kashi Viswanath, Mathura Temple, etc. Barbara Metcalf however highlights political reasons not religious zeal behind destruction of temples.

5.) Arts and Music - He stopped patronage to paintings, artists, etc as not prescribed in shariyat. Manucci writes he banned Music.

Role in Decline of Mughal Empire

→ Jadunath Sarkar views his bigoted policies as main reason for decline. His acts like execution of Guru Teghbahadur, Shambhaji Maharaj alienated Hindus - his subjects. Rajputs, Marathas - became anti-Mughal. Peasants like jats, Satnamis revolted by rallying behind community leader Zamindar.

However, other historians do not see his religious policy as reason for decline. → He inducted Deccani Nobles in nobility → His reign saw increased Percentage of Hindu nobles.

Reasons for decline are therefore sought in systems and institutions intrinsic to Mughal administration.

1) Irfan Habib - exploitative agrarian relation as oppression under Jagirdars - led to Agrarian revolt

2) Satish chandra - jagirdari crisis due to economic crisis in 18th century.

3) Emergence of powerful social groups whom Muzaffar Alam calls upstarts -> jagirdars who defied transfers -> zamindars around whom peasants rallied. with considerable politico-economic and social power.

Thus, Aurangzeb's reign was less tyrannical, less orthodox and less bigoted as held by earlier historiography and his religious policy though contributed to decline but was not main factor.