Topper Copies

"With the best intentions, excellent ideas, but no balance or patience, no sense of proportion, Muhammad Tughluq was a transcendent failure". In the light of this statement, critically examine the experiments of Muhammad bin Tughluq and its failure.

Ashish Raghuwanshi

Muhammad Bin Tughlaq who ruled in 14th century is known for his 'Tughlaqi fasmans' about his various failed experiments.

[Barani] writes in Tarikh-i-Firuzshahi that he was hot and hasty in character. He followed his own judgements and didn't paid attention to others advice.

[Ibn Batuta,] Moroccon traveller mentions different 'manshurs' which he issued.

Experiment of Mohd. Tughlaq

(I) Administrative and Political :-

-> Shifting capital from Delhi to Daulatabad in 1327. -> Khurasan and Qarachil expeditions

Failures 1.) Decision to shift capital to Delhi again at Bubonic plague and revolt when Batuta visits Delhi in 1334 it was fully settled. 2) After raising large army for Expedition, army kept idle for 1 year and then soldiers were asked to leave. Barani says they became robbers.

(II) Economic Measures :-

-> Token Currency introduced -> Taxes in agriculture increased by 10 to 20 times writes Barani -> Strict measures against peasants, Cultivators.

Failures 1.) Barani says 'House of every Hindu became a mint' and later Token currency rolled back. 2.) He faced number of agrarian revolts

Reasons for failure 1.) Was not aware of ground realities. 2.) Dependence on local bureaucracy who were corrupt. 3.) Natural Disasters.

K.A. Nizami concludes that 26 years of reign of Mohd. Tughlaq saw projects and schemes correctly conceived, badly executed and disastrously abandoned.