Discuss the debate of various theories of the origins of Rajputs.
Ashish Raghuwanshi
Origin of Rajput as powerful ruling clans is shrouded in controversy. Pritvirajraso mentions 36 Clans of Rajputs and various aspects of them has been covered by Col. James Tod.
Debate of various theories of Origin of Rajputs
(I) Agnikula Origin - A Myth.
Prithvirajraso mentions Rajput clans of chauhans, chalmanas, Paramaras and Pratiharas as emerging out of sacrifice at Mt. Abu by Vasishta. Herman Kulke says that these Rajputs were of Gurjara stock (Landed classes) and they claimed Agnikula origin to raise status as to level of other chandrawansi and Suryavamshi families
(II) Feudal View
BNS Yadava and D.C. Sircar assigns importance to landlordism in their emergence.
(III) Processual Theory
B.D Chattopadhyay talks of their origin in content of local landed-elite based status in integrative State formation during Early Medieval period.
(E.g.) 1) Gurjars were earlier Hunas and other outsiders and they were Rajputised. 2) Guhila Kingdom emergence by suppressing Bhils.
Thus, the different theories has been based on different sources and B.D Chattopadhyay's works appears to be satisfactory.