To what extent can Germany be held responsible for causing the two World Wars? Discuss critically.
Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024
There are several commonalities between the two world wars fought in the twentieth century prime one being that Germany was the aggressor in both cases. This had not only resulted in harsh consequences for Germany but also made many historians believe it be sole cause of two world wars.
In the case of first world war, Germany had been called as the sole responsible for outbreak of war as it gave a blank cheque to Austria of all support militarily in any war. This made Austria declare an unnecessary war on Serbia despite Serbia agreeing to most Austrian demands by then.
However many historians consider Austria and Russia responsible because they had been building troops. Both had misled that it is just a warning and will not lead to actual war.
Russia is also blamed as after Austria declared war on Germany, Russia attacked Austria which had it not done so, it could have ended in a small war like previous Balkan wars (1912-13)
Thus after the world war, Woodrow Wilson had openly declared that the system of alliances between the nations, the secret military pacts are the chief cause of tension building up. Thus all secret pacts were prohibited and League of Nations was set up
Thus Germany is one of the reasons for the war according to most historians.
In the case of Second world war, historians like Hugh Trevor Roper had blamed Germany solely for the war and depicted Hitler as a pure evil. However other things shoted also be noted . 1. The Allied nations should also be blamed according to some historians for their constant appeasement policy and lack of action at earlier stages . 2. some believed it to be German people along with German leader who also wanted to restore the pride lost after first world war . 3. Historians like Sally Marks blamed the ill drawn and misconcieved treaty like Treaty of versaille was a major cause of seccond world war .
Thus many historians agree that a war of this stature can't be really blamed on a person or a nation but on several interconnected factors .
So was the case with ... both the world wars which because of being initiated by Germany , are blamed on it even till today by some .