Topper Copies

"The treaty of Versailles, which represented "peace" for some and a "diktat" for others, also sowed the seeds of the Second World War." Analyse.

Avdhija Gupta, AIR 43, 2024

While many analysts and politicians had called the Treaty of Versaille as the Peace Treaty, others termed it as 'a peace which ended all peace'. Because it was treated a dictated peace by many, the consequences had to be complex.

At the peace of Versailles, the treaty signed with Germany was extremely humiliating according to some historians. Thus they believed that second world war was inevitable to restore what Germany had lost.

E.H. Carr had pointed out that establishing peace was just one step. What was more important was to enforce peace and it was here that allies failed.

After the war, as Carr has pointed out, the French search for security was obvious as it had faced two major German attacks in past fifty years. Therefore the treaty was not very unreasonable. But looking from Germany's perspective, as pointed out by Andrew Crozier, for a nation like Germany which took so much pride in its military, such a treaty was as humiliating as possible.

Germany has felt the defeat immensely as - 1. It was not allowed to participate in peace but was dictated terms. 2. It had to agree to the war guilt clause. 3. It had to pay huge compensation. 4. Disarmament and other clause.

These grievances are infact pointed out by Hitler in his work and thus historians conclude that it made Hitler bitter and prepared himself for second world war

Ruth Henig however observes that the terms of treaty was basic and were not harassing in long run. A.J.P. Taylor states that Germany still remained by and far most powerful state on European mainland and thus French search for security was evident.

Historians therefore agree that the the treaty of Versaille can bee termed as an important cause of & origin of second world war. However, they donot believe it to be the sole cause since there were other factors like unsettled border disputes, Great depression, faulty system of alliance, mistrust among capitalist and communist state etc.