How significant are the pre/early Harappan sites/villages in Sind and Baluchistan to our understanding of the origins of the Harappan Civilization?
Ashish Raghuwanshi
Origins of the Harappan Civilization has been debated by historians and there are Diffusionist and Evolutionary theory.
Diffusionist Theories were given by Scholars like E.J.H Mackey and Mortimer Wheeler who talked of migration of people and ideas from Sumer (Mesopotamia)
However, on the basis of pre/Early Harappan sites in Sind and Baluchistan, Evolutionary theories are developed.
M.R. Mughal's analysis from site like Sindh's Amri talks of how transition was made from pre-Harappan to Mature Harappan.
[a sketch map of Harappan sites in Sindh and Baluchistan, with a river and dots labelled Mohenjodaro, Kot Diji and Amri; Fig : Harappan Sites in Sindh, Baluchistan]
- Mughal says that Pre-Harappan context in c. 3000 - 2600 BCE is actually Early-Harappan. - Similarly, findings at Kot Diji, an Early Harappan site talks of flourishing Evolution as origin of Harappan Civilisation or IVC.
Features of IVC which are seen in Early Harappan sites :- 1. Fortifications - often mud instead of burnt and baked bricks 2. Evolution of typical Harappan wheel-made - Red Pottery which is pottery with painted black designs. 3. Subsistence Base comprising on plants like wheat barley, animals like sheep, goat, etc. 4. Pottery designs like pipal leaves 5. Crafts, shell working, beads (eg at Allahdino
However, these findings are challenged 1. Sudden break at Kot Diji with burnt deposit between Early and Mature Harappan levels suggest transition was not smooth. 2. No Early Harappan level at sites like Chanhudaro, also in Baluchistan.
Allchins and Allchins write that origin of Harappan Civilisation must be seen in cultural convergence of different regional traditions (eg at Sindh, Baluchistan.
Chakrabarti opines that regional trade, Craft specialisation, agrarian surplus played important role.
Thus, in absence of deciphered script, findings from Early Harappan sites give key insights on origins of IVC.