Evaluate the account of Fa Hien as a source of history of Ancient India. How his account can be compared with the account of Hiuen Tsang?
Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023
Fa Hien visited India from 399-412 AD during the reign of Chandragupta II
Account of Fa Hien: Fu-Kyo-Ki - Prevalence of untouchability - Chandalas had to live in outskirts of city - had to stamp a stick to make others aware of their presence - were involved in unclean activities - Administration - effective and efficient - punishment system was very liberal - capital punishment was absent - even on repeated rebellion, hand was only caught - Cities - were flourishing (ex) Pataliputra - Buddhism - was prevalent in Northern India - talks about visit to Nalanda
Comparison with account of Hiuen Tsang - Buddhism - Hiuen Tsang talks about declining Buddhism in Deccan - Fa Hien doesn't talk about it - Time frame - Hiuen Tsang -> 7th century AD - Fa Hien -> 5th century AD - Buddhist stupas - Hiuen Tsang talks about many built by Ashoka in Samatata, Paundravardhana, Kapisha etc. - Monarchy - Fa-Hien doesn't mention Chandragupta I - Hieun Tsang exaggerates and gives detailed account of Harshavardhana
The tradition of travelling to India to learn about Buddhism was continued by many including Itsing in late 7th century