Critically examine the various views regarding the role of iron technology in ushering Second Urbanisation in Ancient India.
Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023
The later Vedic Age in North India from around 1000BC and Megalithic Age in peninsular India from about 1100BC can be said to be the beginning of iron technology in India.
Iron technology as very important in bringing 2nd urbanisation 1. RS Sharma - use of iron plough made deeper cultivation easier which led to rapid growth of agriculture ushering in urbanisation - iron sickle for harvesting - iron socketed axe for forest clearing also used extensively 2. DD Kosambi - the search for iron led to Indo-Aryans moving into the Eastern India - iron technology made Magadhans stronger
Iron technology as not so important 1. Nihar Ranjan Ray and Chakravarty - refutes RS Sharma's claim - Evidences - only one iron plough found at Jakhera - very few iron axes and sickles - the soil of northern plains was softer and wooden plough was enough - agriculture productivity increased due to wet paddy cultivation (not use of iron) - forests were cleared using fire (Ex) Khandav Vana in Mahabharata 2. Makkhan Lal - opines use of iron for urbanisation is a myth - iron plough not necessary for cultivation - large parts of eastern India were forested upto 16th -17th century AD 3. Counter to Kosambi - movement in quest of iron scarce improbable -> many places iron has been found - Atranjikhera iron points to location between Gwalior and Agra and not eastern Bihar
[a sketch map of India titled "Fig:- early finds of iron", with dots at Jakhera, Noh, Ahar, Watgal, Hallur, Malhar and Raj-Ka-Tila]
4. Regional variations - in South India, early iron finds did not lead to socio-economic progress.
The impact of urbanisation due to iron technology is complex and has to be studied at regional and sub-regional levels