Mention various sources showing the presence of the Indian Republics and factors responsible for their rise in the sixth-fifth centuries B.C. What factors led to their decline?
Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023
Indian republics have coexisted alongwith monarchical form of Government since the beginning of state formations in Vedic age
Sources - Buddhist, Jain and Brahmanical religious sources - Patanjali's Mahabhasya - Panini's Asthadyayi talk about republics like Vrijji, Malla, Lichchavis etc. - Kautilya's Arthashastra - Digha Nikaya
Factors responsible for rise - As reaction against prevailing socio-religious conditions - reaction against rise of hereditary monarchy aided by the Brahmans - reaction against growing caste rigidities and gender discriminations - Breaking away from monarchies - (ex) Shakyas breaking from Kosala Maha-janapada - (ex) similar case with Videha - Opposition by tribal chiefs - as all the resources were occupied by the king - resented for control over land revenue, army, resources etc.
[a sketch map titled "Fig:- Republics of ancient India" marking the Mallas and Vrijjis in the east and the Yaudheyas / Malavas in the centre]
Factors for decline 1. Geographical location - located at foothills of Himalayas or interior forests having less resources (ex) Shakyas 2. loss of virtues - hereditary officials, kings etc. came up which hampered growth 3. Political ambitions of powerful rulers (Ex) - Ajatashatru defeated Vajjis, barocedia- gupta completely wiped off 4. Internal dissensions. (Ex) defeat of Vajjis 5. No standing army - made them weak 6. Conservative attitude - proper weaponry not developed
Although republics had democratic values like large assembly (Vajjis - 7707 members) however, their democratic elements were limited as power was not exercised by all which points Upinder Singh to consider them as oligarchies.