“Railway development in India provides an interesting instance of private enterprise at public risk”. Explain.
Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023
The development of railways started in India after the opening of the first railway line from Bombay to Thane in 1853
Instance of private enterprise - As developed through British financial capital which was allowed to be invested by Charter Act of 1833 - Even coal, railway tracks all were provided by private sector
At public risk - it was developed under a 5% guarantee system - So, if there was any loss, it had to been by the Government or the public
Unique - as loss was public - profit was private
Effects Negatives - drain of wealth - broke self-sufficiency of Indian villages - as opined by OH Buchanan - destroyed handicraft industries - strengthened British rule
Positive - created sense of unity among Indians - strengthened nationalism - ex:- Home Rule experts
In the words of Marx, 'the effects of railways in India would be same as witnessed all across the world' benefiting India in the long run.