Topper Copies

"It is difficult to avoid the conclusion that the so-called first national war of independence of 1857 is neither first, nor national, nor a war of independence." Comment.

Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023

R C Majumdar commented that the revolt of 1857 was neither first, nor national, nor a war of independence. Contrarily, Savarkar opines that it was the first war of Indian independence

Not the first war - More than 40+ revolts had taken place before 1857 against British rule - ex:- Santhal Hul, 1855

As first war - in terms of extent - almost whole North India was affected - in terms of participation - peasants, tribals, princes, landlords etc. participated unlike earlier isolated movements - in terms of difficulties faced by British - never seen before

Not national - There was no vision of India as we understand it today - People were fighting for narrow interests - eg:- Rani Lakshmi Bai for Jhansi - Nana Saheb to get his pension

As national movement - The concept of nation is dynamic in nature - Jhansi was nation for Laxmi Bai - Opinions - Benjamin Disraeli suggests that it was national movement

Not war of independence - Rebels were not fighting for the independence of India - They were fighting for local issues

As war of independence - Fought for their independence - eg:- Begum Hazrat Mahal for Awadhis independence - Wider viewpoint of rebels - had vision of atleast independence of Mughal India as they put Bahadur Shah Zafar on the throne - The idea of India is dynamic in nature

Other viewpoints - Sepoy Mutiny or mass movement - Many opine that it was a mutiny of selfish army - Many think it was a mass movement - large no of hangings in Benaras - large civilian participation as seen in places like Lucknow - Elitist vs non-elitist in nature - few opine it was elitist in nature - however, it was non-elitist as - sepoys were the main rebels who were common people - masses forced leaders to take up fight when they were not willing - eg:- Bahadur Shah Zafar - Planned or unplanned - Many think it was unplanned in nature - Charles Ball points to regular panchayats in sepoy lines which points to some sort of organisation.

The revolt of 1857 forced British to change its ideology 'of one governed by caution and conservatism' in words of Thomas Metcalf.