“The partition of India was neither inevitable nor the product of sheer chance. It was not the fulfilment of destiny or the logical outcome of the two nation theory; nor was it simply an accident that was produced by a single wrong decision or failure of judgement. The partition of India was the product of complex processes and was the outcome of several factors.” In the light of the given statement, discuss various factors responsible for the partition of India.
Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023
The partition of India was one of the most bloodiest events in Indian history killing millions and making 8 Crore people homeless in their own country.
Factors responsible for partition - The two nation theory propagated by Muslim league (ML) - RJ Moore, Mushirul Hasan etc. suggest persistent efforts of ML led to partition - Arrogance of Indian National Congress - after its resounding victory in 1937 elections - led ML to persuade radical politics of fear mongering among Muslims - wiping out other Muslim parties - creating fear among Muslims (eg fabricated reports like Pirpur Report - Role of Hindu organisations - like Hindu Mahasabha which followed radical Hindu nationalism - Role of British - 'divide and rule' policy widened religious gaps - eg:- separate electorates, 1909 - supporting Muslim league - Cold War compulsions - led British in need of a state which they can dominate -> led to creation of Pakistan - fear of India siding with USSR - Failure of Indian National Congress - to mainstream most of the Muslim population in the freedom movement - Achin Vanaik says Congress cannot escape from responsibility of partition of India - Anion Roy suggests it was Congress who finally decided to cut a knife across India - Role of change in perception of nation - In 1920s, a secularist view of nation was put forwarded by Nehru - anybody who spoke about community was considered as communal alienating Muslims - Close association of Congress and Hindu Mahasabha - led to Muslim alienation - Shaukat Ali commented, 'Congress had become an adjunct of the Hindu Mahasabha' - Role of Muhammad Ali Jinnah - very adept leader who could persuade large section of Muslim population to agree to partition.
The partition of India had large impact on large sections of people - most intense in Punjab - many lost lives and properties - women were the worst affected as said by Kamla Bhasin.
Due to partition, the joy of independence was marred as - Gandhiji spent day in prayer and fasting - MAK Azad mention in India Wins Freedom that he was in a gloomy mood - Hindu nationalists offered
As we stand at the cusp of 75 years of independence, partition should guide us to avoid the mistakes we committed so that India remains strong and united.