“To characterize the Quit India Movement as ‘Spontaneous Revolution’ or as the culmination of Gandhian Satyagraha movements would be partial interpretation”. Elucidate.
Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023
The Quit Indian movement was launched by Congress on 8th August, 1942 from Gowalia Tank with Gandhiji's clarion call for ‘Do or Die’
As Spontaneous Revolution - It was completely violent and unplanned from the beginning - Sumit Sarkar says in the 2nd and 3rd phase destruction of railway tracks, telegraph lines happened in large scale - Parallel Governments were established without help of mainstream leader - ex:- Chittu Pandey in Balia - In words of Linlithgow, ‘it was by far the most serious rebellion since 1857’ - Gyanendra Pandey suggests Gandhiji had little control over the movement of which he was the leader
Not entirely spontaneous as - Base prepared by mass movements - of last two decades, by associate organisations of Congress like AIKS, AITUS, CSP, Forward Bloc which were more radical in nature - Preparation of 12 point plan - by Congress before its leaders were arrested - included satyagraha, non-payment of taxes, restriction of telegraph and railway lines etc. - Gandhiji's general instructions to people - beforehand
As Culmination of Gandhian satyagraha - complete mass participation - Women participated in large numbers ex - Aruna Asaf Ali, Usha Mehta etc. - workers and peasants participation - native states participated - Democratic and inclusive in character - Gandhi's call for non-violence - appreciating Prati Sarkar of Satara and hoping people will be non-violent
Departure from Gandhian movements - Not restrained - all out war which was never abandoned - Violent from beginning - Gandhi unlike earlier movement, didn't condemn violence and held British Government responsible for it - Unplanned revolution - As per Gyanendra Pandey, Gandhiji provided psychological break to people by telling them to act as they wish - Participation of native states - took place unlike earlier Gandhian movements.
The Quit India movement was the most massive attack on British and ultimately forced British to leave India.