"Governor's office is neither decorative nor inconsequential - it assumes a constitutional role of profound essence". To what extent does the Governor actively contribute to governance of a state, and reinforce principles of federalism?
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
Article 153 describes office of Governor, and Article 154 describes the office as one in which all the executive power of the state is vested.
Governor, to a significant extent, contributes to the governance of a state, and to principles of federalism.
Contribution to governance, and federalism 1. Article 153: "All executive action ... in name of Governor" 2. Article 163: Discretionary power to governor 3. Article 166: Governor to make rules for convenient transaction of business 4. Article 167: "Duties of chief minister to Governor" → inform Governor about ALL executive action taken, i.e, it is Governor's responsibility, to ensure governance is in accordance with constitution 5. Article 200, 201: giving assent to legislation; withholding assent if it is against constitution, etc. 6. Article 356: Governor can report to President (if administration is not in accordance with constitution) 7. Administration of scheduled areas - 5th and 6th schedule. 8. As Chancellor of universities.
Thus, as Punchhi and Sarkaria commission have noted, Governor is the lynchpin to the federal scheme in the constitution.
Issues that have gone against principles of federalism 1. Partisan functioning 2. Interference with State Executive 3. Misuse of Article 356 - (eg.) during 1975-77, 78-80 and 81-84 4. Delay in giving assent to legislation - (eg.) Jallikattu legislation in Tamil Nadu
Hence, Supreme Court has observed in BP Singhal case (2010), Nabam Rebia case (2016) and Shamsher Singh case: "Doctrine of Pleasure without responsibility doesn't exist in Indian Constitution"