Topper Copies

"The Hindus believe that there is no science like theirs." In the light of this statement, give a critical analysis of Al Beruni's account of Indian science.

Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023

Al Beruni was an Arabic scholar who come to India along with Mahmud Ghazni in 11th century AD.

Al Beruni's account of Indian Science

Praises - Indians as having rich scientific knowledge among people of the size - credits for discovery of decimal system and for first understanding use of zero - praises astronomy as close to them and talks about Aryabhata, Varahmihira etc. - talks about chemical science and Nagarjuna - does not mention Sushruta Samhita but mentions Charak Samhita - praises India's weights and measures system

Al Beruni criticises - superiority complex of Hindus believing that there is no science like theirs - compares alchemy to witchcraft and Indians as sorcerers - talks about Indians as good mathematics and excellent philosophers but considers himself superior - talks about present stagnation

SAA Rizvi points out that he was one of the foremost scholars to visit India