"The religious policies of Aurangzeb were controversial in nature and were guided by his puritanical mind." Critically analyse by giving proper examples.
Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023
Aurangzeb ascended the throne after winning the succession battles most notably against Dara Shukoh and ruled from about 1658-1707 AD
Religious policies giving controversial in nature and guided by puritanical mind
1. Reversed secular policies of predecessors (ex) Jizya was reimposed in 1679 2. Strict restrictions on practices of Hindus (ex) public celebration of festivals banned in 1668 3. Demolition of old temples - from 1658 orders - Mathura etc. - and also new temples (1668-69) 4. Deccan policy of conquest - one reason was the Shiite nature of Golconda and Bijapur leading to annexation in 1686 5. Minimalism - removing golden curtains of palace - whitewashing paintings of Akbar's tomb at Sikandra - closing down music's practice and banishing musicians
Controversies of nature
1. Religious bigotry and zealousy - Wanted to impose Sharia laws, orthodox Sunni Islam (opinion by JN Sarkar, Ishwari Prasad) - (1st) jizya imposed as opportunity to suppress Hindus after death of Jaswant Singh - Censoring of morals - department established for the same - Suppressing mystiques (Ex) killing of Sarmand - himself a devout Muslim - called Zinda Pir (living saint) 2. Not a bigot - patronised temples (Ex) Umananda at Guwahati - temples destroyed only during wartime - felt temples centres of internal subversion and rebellion - Audrey Truschke - with increasing rebellions felt legitimate even to destroy long standing temples 3. Religious policies guided by other reasons - Fiscal compulsions (Ex) for imposition of jizya (S Chandra) - To gain support of the Ulmas - as helped in succession battle (liberals supported Dara Shukoh) - state facing numerous challenges - support for orthodox 'Irani and Turani' requi-red [?] - lack of capable Rajput commanders - after death of Jai Singh and Jaswant Singh forced reorientation in relation [?]
Jadunath Sarkar feels that Aurangzeb's policies particularly religious were responsible for downfall of Mughal empire.