Question of gender equality is central to debate on UCC. What are the challenges in reconciling UCC with gender equality as enshrined in the constitution?
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
The Uniform Civil Code (Article 44) is referred to as the "unfulfilled dream of the nation's founding fathers".
Gender equality is enshrined in Articles 14-16 of the constitution (and also Article 39, etc.)
Gender equality central to debate on UCC 1. UCC deals with uniform personal laws - marriage, divorce, adoption, maintenance, inheritance, etc. 2. India being a largely patriarchal society, personal laws are biased against women. 3. Examples: - triple talaq - halala - maintenance of 2nd wife under Hindu code - differing age of marriage for boys and girls (21 and 18 respectively) 4. Hindu women did not have right to property before codification of Hindu laws. 5. Many Muslim laws are still not even codified → disproportionately biased against women.
Challenges in reconciling gender equality and UCC 1. Articles 25, 26 - Article 26 gives religious denomination freedom to manage religious affairs - This has been interpreted by courts and legal experts to mean that personal laws are not subject to judicial review. 2. Lack of codification of all laws 3. State interference in personal matters → against principle of liberty 4. Implementation issues: constitutional morality v/s public morality
Way forward 1. Immediate codification of all personal laws 2. Codification will allow us to understand the extent of gender inequity 3. This will then enable the state to take appropriate steps across all religions