Topper Copies

"Electoral bonds are a double edged sword, providing anonymity to donors while raising concerns around transparency." To what extent have electoral bonds further legitimized opacity in electoral funding?

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

Electoral bonds are non-interest bearing, promissory notes, introduced by Finance Act 2017, to ensure political funding is not done using black money.

In this context:

Transparency concerns of electoral bonds 1. Bonds carry no ownership information. 2. Political party has no compulsion to disclose name of donor 3. Donor: no compulsion to disclose 4. If donor is a corporate entity: no limits, no disclosure required. 5. Violates citizens' "right to information", about their representatives 6. Potential concerns about foreign interference via corporate entities. 7. Donors have to purchase electoral bonds from designated SBI bank branch - SBI being a PSU bank - govt may have information about all donors - information asymmetry, lack of level playing field

At the same time, they have increased transparency 1. KYC necessary to buy bonds. 2. Have to be purchased digitally (i.e, money is transferred digitally) → it can be traced → ensures black money does not come into political system. 3. Preserves privacy of donors. 4. SBI would maintain identity of all buyers, for investigation later, if needed.

Analysis 1. While issue of black money has been addressed, lack of transparency still exists. 2. Concern of foreign interference has been voiced by Election Commission in SC. 3. Need to balance privacy and transparency

Way forward Voluntary disclosure. (eg.) by Jharkhand party JMM - received Rs 1 cr bond from Hindalco.