Give a comparative analysis of the Indus Valley Civilisation and Rig Vedic Culture.
Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023
Scholars like SR Rao, R G Bhandarkar etc. are of the opinion that the people of Rig Vedic culture or the Aryans were the same as people of Indus Valley civilisation.
The various similarities between them are:-
i) Geography:- Both occupied the same geographical region i.e. North-West parts of the subcontinent
ii) Both used pottery
ii) Both used wheel for making pottery
iii) Material culture - Both used metals like copper, bronze, tin etc. None used iron.
The differences are:-
i) Indus valley civilisation (IVC) - urban people, settled in cities Rig Vedic Culture (RVC) - live pastoral in villages
ii) IVC - subsistence based on agricultural industries and trade RVC - pastoral economy largely; agriculture in lower level as found by R N Nandi
ii) IVC - peace loving people; only one sword has been found at Bhagwanpura which seems to be of Vedic age RVC - warrior people ex:- Battle of Ten kings at the banks of Parushni
iv) IVC - bull was worshipped; bronze bull figures from Kalibangan, Lothal etc. RVC - cow was worshipped
v) IVC - mother Goddess main deity RVC - Indra, Varuna, Agni chief deities; female Goddess like Usha, Aditi less in no.
vi) IVC - evidences of centralised administration from twin cities of Harappa and Mohenjodaro RVC - tribal state with not well developed monarchy
vii) IVC - script was known; found extensively in seals and potteries RVC - script not known; education imparted orally
viii) IVC - extensive trade networks with internal trade, trade with Mesopotamian civilisation, Dilmun, Magan etc. RVC - largely internal trade
The Indus valley civilisation has far more differences rather than similarities with Rig Vedic culture. The Aryans settled in this region after the indigenous Harappan people had largely migrated towards western and southern parts of the subcontinent.