Topper Copies

Analyse the significance of various foreign accounts as a source of ancient Indian history.

Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023

Over the ages, various foreign travellers, ambassadors have visited this country which provided valuable info of their age and times. The significance is as follows:-

i) Social life - Megasthenes in Indica talks about various castes in India - Information that Chandalas used to live outside city is provided by Fa Hien

ii) Economic life - Periplus of the erythrean sea provides information about various ports like Bharuch etc. - We know that Romans were addicted to Indian textiles, spices etc. from Pliny's books.

iii) Political life - Hiuen Tsang gives information about extent of Harsha's kingdom - Megasthenes talks about Seleucus handing over various territories like Herat etc. to Chandragupta Maurya

iv) Religious life - Alberuni in Kitab-ul-Hind criticises the Brahmanas for keeping information only to themselves - Fa Hien, Itsing etc. give accounts of Buddhist literature

v) Cultural life

At the same time, it should be noted that foreign accounts suffer from various issues:-

i) Lack of understanding of Indian practices - ex:- Megasthenes stating that slavery was absent

ii) Bias towards patrons

ex:- Hieun Tsang glorified Harsha in Si-Yu-Ki

iii) Many books have been only lost and preserved from writings of others. So, authenticity is compromised.

ex:- Megasthenes Indica only known from writers like Strabo, Pliny, Arrian, Aelian etc.

Thus, foreign accounts are of great significance to understand ancient Indian history but at the same time they should be verified with other literary and archaeological evidences.