In context of border security, how can coop and coord between diff security agencies be improved to ensure effective and efficient management of coastal and terrestrial borders?
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
Security apparatus of India involves variety of agencies, including ground border forces, intelligence agencies, research orgs, etc.
In this context, cooperation and coordination between them can go a long way in making borders more secure:
Terrestrial borders (I) Better cooperation between border forces 1. BSF - Pakistan, Bangladesh border. 2. Assam Rifles - Myanmar border 3. ITBP - China border 4. SSB - Nepal, Bhutan border.
Thus, border forces are distinct, but border challenges are the same (e.g drug trafficking - from golden triangle and golden crescent; arms smuggling, etc).
Hence, border forces need interoperability to jointly combat organized crime. Case study: one part of illegal arms is smuggled via Myanmar, another via Nepal, finally assembled in India - need agencies to work together to combat the joint nature of threats
Hence, Kargil Review committee recommended "One nation one border force"
(II) Better coordination between intelligence agencies 1. Internal intelligence - IB; external intelligence - R&AW; financial intelligence - DRI/FIU, etc. 2. Yet, nature of threat is convergent (e.g money laundering). 3. Hence, need to stop working in silos. 4. Realtime platform for information sharing -> more effective and efficient management.
(III) Links of border threats to other crimes 1. e.g cattle smuggling via West Bengal 2. Hence, coordination with State Police is also a must.
Maritime borders (I) Better coordination of Navy, Coast Guard and State Coastal Police - ie, clear demarcation of responsibility
(II) Unified sea command for coastal districts - set up after 26/11 attacks - for effective management. (III) New institution: commander, Coastal command (after 26/11) - responsible for centre-state coordination -> more effective maritime security.
Thus, as experience post 26/11 with maritime security shows, cooperation and coordination can go a long way in security of borders via information sharing, interoperability, and joint logistics