"On circumstantial evidence Indra stands accused." Discuss the given statement in the context of the decline of Harappan Civilisation.
Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023
The scholars like V Gordon Childe, John Marshall etc. Mortimer Wheeler who put up the theory of Aryan invasion of Harappan decline accuse Indra for the same.
Evidences in support
i) In Vedic literature, Indra has been referred to as 'Purandar' and 'Vritrahana' - a) 'Purandar' refers to destroyer of forts - so, they opine that there were the forts of the Harappan people which was destroyed by Indra - b) 'Vritrahana' means slayer of demon 'Vritra' - it is mentioned that Vritra used to block and change the course of rivers - it might refer to the dams used for flood irrigation by the Harappans
ii) Further, there is a reference to a place called 'Hariyupiya' in Rig Veda where the Aryans fought with the Dasyus - the place has been identified as 'Harappa'
iii) Archaeological evidence - 36 body remains are found at Mohenjodaro which are scattered here and there indicating possibility of a war
There are various drawbacks to this theory
i) Archaeological evidence suggests that in the North-Western region of the subcontinent, the Harappan civilization had already declined by 1750 BC and the Aryans didn't enter before 1500 BC.
ii) The skeletons found in Mohenjodaro belong to different stratigraphic levels as found by G.F. Dales.
iii) The people had recovered from injuries before their death. So, it doesn't point to a war.
Thus, the theory of Aryan invasion is not accepted largely. On the contrary, after evidences found by AN Ghosh, MR Mughal, Allchins etc., the theory of gradual decline is the most acceptable