"The Treaty of Versailles was not a peace settlement but a twenty year armistice." Examine the role of the weaknesses of the post World War I order in the origin of World War 2.
Anjit A Nayar, AIR 205, 2023
It is often claimed by some historians that the Treaty of Versailles wasn't a peace settlement but a twenty year armistice.
Weakness of post World War I International order
- The Treaty of Versailles instead of leaving a just peace, as envisaged by Roosevelt, was a harsh peace - It didn't leave Germany weak enough not to retaliate, thus very soon Germany reclaimed its industrial and economic preeminence. - Weakness of League of Nation. - Didn't include major powers like USA. - Couldn't ensure collective peace as it was more of a British and French affair. - Isolationist attitude of America deprived the world order of an important player to resolve disputes - Shaky fiscal grounds of most European nations and rise of Fascism and Nazism.
Role of Weakness in origin of World War 2
- Disunity between France and Britain led to no check on aggressive posturing of other nations like Italy. - Harsh Treaty of Versailles was part of the reason why policy of appeasement had public support. - Weakness of League of Nations couldn't ensure sec collective security as evident from Japan's invasion of Manchuria. - Germany soon rose to pre-eminence under Hitler. - No penalities were imposed for violation of provisions of Treaty of Versailles - example) re-armament and introduction of conscription - The strength of the democratic government which agreed to the peace settlement rested on strong economic recovery. - With the Wall street Crash, Europe was plunged into the Great Depression which led to the rise of right wing governments who opposed the treaty.
Thus the weakness of post World War I had an important role in origin of World War 2.