Constitution is a mere skeleton whereas constitutionalism is the soul of democracy. Discuss.
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
The fundamental difference between constitution and constitutionalism is that constitutionalism is the CONCEPT of limiting the powers of the STATE, constitution is the means of doing so.
Constitutionalism as the soul of democracy is the end, constitution is merely the means.
How constitution is merely skeleton 1. Written document → fixed 2. Defines structure of govt (LS, RS, State govts, etc.) 3. Defines rights of citizens and duties of state - (eg.) Article 21: "no person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty unless allowed by procedure established by law" - Literal interpretation: A.K. Gopalan case: if procedure allows, right to life can be taken away. 4. Literal interpretation - (eg.) Shankari Prasad case (1951): "constitutional amendments not considered law under Article 13, and hence can take away fundamental rights"
Constitutionalism is the soul of democracy 1. Makes constitution a living breathing document 2. Allows for expansive interpretation, to meet aspirations of citizens - (eg.) Article 21: → "due process of law"; "life is not merely breathing, it is living with choice and dignity" → right to clean environment, education, privacy, etc. 3. Interpretation in spirit - (eg.) Kesavananda Bharati judgement: "constitutional amendments can't change the IDEA of INDIA" → evolution of Basic Structure Doctrine (BSD) 4. Free and fair elections, democracy, federalism, etc are part of BSD → soul of democracy
Thus, without constitutionalism, constitution is merely a fancy book.