On one hand, Gandhiji withdrew the Non-Cooperation Movement on the issue of violence at Chauri-Chaura but on the other hand he had refused to condemn people's violence during the Quit India Movement. Does it show that he was losing faith in the efficacy of non-violence and was willing to deviate from this path?
Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023
Gandhiji in Hind Swaraj highlights non-violence as a cardinal virtue which cannot be compromised at any cost.
Violence and non-cooperation movement 1. Gandhiji urged people to strictly follow non-violent methods 2. Withdrew as violence in Chauri Chaura on 5 Feb, 1922
Despite withdrawing because of violence, other reasons also as - Already more than a year had passed and common people can't fight forever - in line with philosophy of 'struggle - truce - struggle'
So, belief in non-violence was coupled with practical considerations from beginning
Stance in Quit India movement - ambivalent - on 5 August 1942 announced that he didn't want his non-violence from the people and everyone was free to pursue own course - praised to Nana Patil (Prati Sarkar) about non-violence but said "I am someone who prefers violence of the brave rather than non-violence of the cowardly" - blamed British Govt for the violence and refused to condemn the people
Not losing faith in efficacy of non-violence as 1. Didn't condone people's violence 2. Still praised those who were non-violent 3. Urged people to raise a non-violent movement 4. Never followed any violent means - pursued satyagraha only
Not willing to deviate from path 1. Continued faith in non-violence and calls for a non-violent movement
But other needs equally important 1. Indian independence - was an equally relevant goal for which Gandhiji fought throughout his life - QIM had gained such momentum that couldn't be withdrawn for stray violent incidents 2. Always followed non-violence within practical limits - (ex) not withdrawing civil disobedience movement when violence erupted at Chittagong 3. Chances of Japanese conquest - need to revive power into India's hand
In conclusion, faith of Gandhiji in non-violence unwavering but conditions such that were some compromise was inevitable.