Topper Copies

Discuss the reasons of failure at finding solution to the India's constitutional deadlock during 1942-1946.

Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023

Numerous attempts were made to resolve Constitutional deadlocks during 1942-46 but all of them eventually failed in providing a solution

Attempts and reasons of failure

1. Cripps Mission, 1942 Provisions - To form a constituent assembly after the war - Participation of native states in federation - through nomination - Election of members by proportional representation etc.

Failed as -> opposed by all groups - Congress - post dated cheque on dominion status was given - nomination of princely state members - threat to unity of nation - as provinces could reject constitution - Muslim league (ML) - no mention of Pakistan - no provision of separate electorates

2. Rajagopalachari Plan, 1944 Provisions - Congress and ML would work together for independence - Decision of partition - to be taken after independence by plebiscite in Muslim majority areas

Failed as:- ML objections - issue of partition to be decided before independence - decision to be taken by plebiscite in which only Muslims will vote

3. Desai-Liaqat Pact, 1945 Provisions - Congress and ML to have equal representation in interim Govt - 20% reservation for Muslims in Constituent Assembly

Failed as -> Jinnah opposed as talks were carried on without his consultation

4. Wavell Plan, 1945 Provisions - Executive Council to be expanded immediately - Indians to form Constituent with only Governor General and Commander as British representatives - Caste Hindu and Muslims to have equal seats

Failed as -> - ML insisted on being the sole representative of the Muslims - Wavell did not pursue deal enough to reject demands of the ML.

5. Cabinet Mission Plan, 1946 Provisions - One Indian union with centre having powers of defence, foreign affairs, currency and communication - Provinces to have all other powers - Groupings - A - Hindu majority - B - Muslim majority - C - Assam, Bengal - Provinces can come out of grouping after 5 years

Failed as -> oppositions by all - Congress - weak centre - didn't like North West Frontier (NWFP) Province being in Group B (Muslim majority) - wanted groups to question Constitution before 10 yrs (had NWFP, Assam in mind) - ML - initially accepted on June 6 as (having Pakistan inherently) - Later rejected as Congress told the opposite

Deadlock continued till Independence Act in June 1947