Topper Copies

"Why did the British finally quit India on 15th August 1947? The imperialist answer is that independence was simply the fulfilment of British self-appointed mission to assist the Indian people to self-government." Critically Examine.

Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023

The British left India on 15 August, 1947 after about 200 years of rule and but not before extreme exploitation and partition.

Reasons for British quitting India

1. Imperialist answer - fulfilment of British self-appointed mission Schools → British Liberals (eg) Macaulay, Ripon - felt it was a civilising mission

→ Utilitarian - need of effective schoolmaster (JS Mill) → to make India self-governing in future

Arguments given 1. Gradual devolution of powers (eg) Govt of India Act, 1919 → 1935 Act - dyarchy in province → provincial autonomy 2. Indian nationalism as 'Child of the British Raj' - due to British efforts like Western education, institutions like judiciary etc. 3. To lead India out from darkness - justified by Oriental school which says about past degeneration → British paternalism 4. Gradual increase in franchise (en) 10% enfranchised by GOI Act, 1935

However, (not correct) as 1. Gradual devolution - only to consolidate power - Linlithgow quoted about 1935 Act 'they enacted it as they felt it was the best way to hold India to the empire' 2. Non-fulfilment of promises (Ex) Dominion status guaranteed during Civil Disobedience movement not given in 1935 Act 3. Guided by attempts to weaken Congress (Ex) provincial autonomy - to break them into fiefdoms

Other reasons for quitting 1. Strength of Indian national movement - gradually increasing to reach Quit India movement completely violent and uncontrolled from the beginning 2. Revolutionary efforts (Ex) Indian National Army by SC Bose 3. Cumulative effect on army - gradually shaking the last strength of British - (ex) Royal Indian Naval Mutiny '1946 4. International reasons - World War II and need for Indian support putting pressure on Churchill to give India concessions 5. Commitments - BN Pandey opines that the Labour Party was committed for Indian independence since a long time 6. British prestige at stake - as communal riots were engulfing India and British were a mute spectator.

All these combined together to result in British leaving India in 1947.