'Clive was not a planner of empire, but an experimenter who revealed some of the possibility.' Critically examine.
Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023
Robert Clive was one of the early figures of British colonisation in India who has been hailed mostly by the British writers as 'the founder of the empire'
Not a planner but an experimenter 1. Siege of Arcot, 1753 (2nd Carnatic War) - defended Arcot for 53 days with very less men - experiment paid off as Nawab of Carnat had to relieve force to re-capture capital 2. Bribing to recapture Alinagar, Jan' 1757 of Daulah - success as corrupt officials gave Alinagar to R Clive 3. Battle of Plassey '1757 - individual effort as was not agreed to by his senior Watson 4. Dual Government in Bengal - huge suffering to people - not feasible in long run
Elements of planning visible 1. Signing treaties (Ex) Treaty of Allahabad, 1765 with Nawab of Awadh after Buxar battle → provided for subsidiary alliance 2. Attempts to curb misuse of Company's income.
R Clive can be at max called 'a Conquistador' who succeeded in his experiments to a large extent.