Examine how far the differences in the nature of the English and French East India Companies explain the failure of the French in India.
Anjit A Nayar, AIR 205, 2023
The French and the British were the last remaining European contenders to the trade and political crown of India.
The English EIC and the French EIC had some fundamental differences in their nature, that had contributed to the defeat of French EIC.
- Nature of Company. - English EIC was a private company were shareholders played an important role in the affairs of the company. - French EIC had a major stake with the French monarch was least bit interested in managing the affairs of the company. - Being a private company, the British EIC never neglected their commercial and economic interests, thus had a strong financial base, to wage war. - The French EIC neglected its commercial and economic interests thus was not able to consolidate its rule and win against British. - The British EIC was devolved greater power in decision making thus was able to handle any new circumstances. - The French EIC had to always look upto the government for approval. This delayed decision making thus making the company ineffecient. - The EIC had support of the home government to meet any exigencies like financial constraint or in the form of provision of crown troops. - The French EIC didn't have much help from their home government and thus was mostly left to themselves to deal with any exigencies.
But at the same time there were factors too that ensured British victory like:
- Superior navy and ability to establish naval blockade. - Access to resources of Bengal to fund their war and finance their trade. - Able leaders were many in British EIC like Clive, Arthur Wellesly. While for French EIC, Dupleix was the sole able man.
Thus failure of French in India against British can be partly explained due to the Differences in nature of British and French EIC.