Topper Copies

Was it the weakening of the Mughal empire or the rise of regional powers that led to the British conquest of India? Discuss.

Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025

The decline of Mughals and advent of British has been debated upon regional basis and empire-centric basis by the scholars.

Role of weakening of Mughal Empire :-

- Presence of weak successors. post-Aurangzeb & Eg. Rangeela - Expansion of empire beyond scientific boundaries - Religious intolerance (Jadunath Sarkar) - Decline in character of nobility - Eg. Sayyid Brothers killed Mughal emperor - External invasions of Afghans - Eg Nadir Shah in 1739, Abdali in 1748 - Such conditions created 'political void' in India - Mughal emperors became puppets to external actors. - As British became economically & politically dense, they were able to control him and through him the Indian politics

Rise of Regional Powers

- Historians like Chetan Singh & Muzaffar Alam do not accept Mughal decline for weakening for its decline - They favour regional factors :- - Eg Punjab and Bengal emerged as regional powers due to trade and economic prosperity - Local groups like warrior-peasant groups => Jat, Sikh, Maratha became politically strong - Both Regional actors had narrow sense of nationalism and mostly aligned to their own self interests. - Eg. Mysore - Maratha - Hyderabad conflicts: They seeked help of external actors to balance their native counterparts - Eg Nizam of Hyderabad against Maratha [?] - Native rulers seeked advanced European artillery, soldiers against neighbours. - [?] to British to - This allowed opportunity! Gradually, they interfere in Indian politics: transformed from mere suppliers and supporters to the controllers of regional group.

Hence the rotten state of Mughals, regionalisation of polity and [?] helped in British advent in India