Topper Copies

Critically analyse whether the success of the Mughals is to be credited to their robust jagirdari and Mansabdari system.

Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025

Mughals have been appreciated for developing a sophisticated 'military-bureaucratic' system called Mansabdari-jagirdari system.

Mansabdari-jagirdari as source of Mughal [?]

- Centralisation of Authority - Expanded influence of emperor to most periphery as per Abul Fazl 'Ain-i-Akbari'. - uniformity across empire in administration - Alternate power centre to subahdar who was susceptible to revolts - Mobilisation governing - Irfan Habib suggests efficient revenue collecting during Akbar with mansabdari - Jagirdari - Social Mobility - Shireen Moosvi opines the inclusion of composite nobility like Rajputs as mansabdars - expansion of area under cultivation - Mesitrious soldiers in service of emperor through mansabdars - composite military

Limitations of Mansabdari-Jagirdari system

- Degraded with time by :- Jahangir's Si Aspa Du Aspa , Shah Jahan's month scale and Aurangzeb's Masshut . - Caused crisis in empire - J.F Richards & Athar Ali blame it for Mughal decline => poor management and large number of Jagirdars who competed for good Jagirs. Caused beijagiri) - Exploitation of peasants caused agrarian crisis and peasant revolt (Irfan Habib, Nurul Hasan) - Military degradation - soldiers loyal to Mansabdar - Led to self train

Thus, Mansabdari & Jagirdari system was both boon and bane to Mughals, who caused rise in efficient management and rotting of Mughal rule in its decline