Critically analyse whether the success of the Mughals is to be credited to their robust jagirdari and Mansabdari system.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
Mughals have been appreciated for developing a sophisticated 'military-bureaucratic' system called Mansabdari-jagirdari system.
Mansabdari-jagirdari as source of Mughal [?]
- Centralisation of Authority - Expanded influence of emperor to most periphery as per Abul Fazl 'Ain-i-Akbari'. - uniformity across empire in administration - Alternate power centre to subahdar who was susceptible to revolts - Mobilisation governing - Irfan Habib suggests efficient revenue collecting during Akbar with mansabdari - Jagirdari - Social Mobility - Shireen Moosvi opines the inclusion of composite nobility like Rajputs as mansabdars - expansion of area under cultivation - Mesitrious soldiers in service of emperor through mansabdars - composite military
Limitations of Mansabdari-Jagirdari system
- Degraded with time by :- Jahangir's Si Aspa Du Aspa , Shah Jahan's month scale and Aurangzeb's Masshut . - Caused crisis in empire - J.F Richards & Athar Ali blame it for Mughal decline => poor management and large number of Jagirdars who competed for good Jagirs. Caused beijagiri) - Exploitation of peasants caused agrarian crisis and peasant revolt (Irfan Habib, Nurul Hasan) - Military degradation - soldiers loyal to Mansabdar - Led to self train
Thus, Mansabdari & Jagirdari system was both boon and bane to Mughals, who caused rise in efficient management and rotting of Mughal rule in its decline