Topper Copies

Q.7 (c) Discuss the applicabillity of Segmentary State Model for Chola state. How other models tried to explain the nature of the Chola kingdom? [20 Marks]

Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023

The segmentary state model for Chola state was put forward by Burton Stein based on ideas of Southall who had initially applied it for tribal societies in Africa.

Applicability - Stein argues that - land revenue of the state was very low and they survived on looting - Chola state was united by ritualistic practices and social kingship - argues that there was no large standing army and the armies of the feudal lords were much more in number - There was Brahmana-peasant alliance against the weak state

Not applicable as - Stein ignores the basis of enduring power and military access of the Cholas - looting was part of all ancient and medieval kingdoms like Mauryas, Guptas etc. but they had something more - U Singh opines Stein confuses coercive power with centralised state - this model cannot be applied to stable civilised societies like Cholas - Karasimha's study shows that Chola inscriptions had large number of officials names showing centralising attempts.

Other models of Chola state 1. Centralised with autonomy [KAN Shastri] - officers like Nadu Vaggi, Ayagars for centralised control over villages - however, local issues resolved by local Committees (variyams) - sufficient autonomy 2. Feudal state [RS Sharma, OD Koshambi] - state bound by feudal lords and allegiance to the Chola monarch 3. Archaic state - despotic monarchy - oppressive collection of land revenue - no welfare measures and poor condition of peasants - Asiatic mode of production 4. Others - studies show (Heitzman) about Chola kings attempts changing taxation (not much power of peasants) - Chola's conquests of Sri Lanka, Sumatra etc. prove its strong monarchy

It can be concluded that there were regionalistic variations of centralisation in (say) core Kaveri delta compared to Andhra, Karnataka etc.