Q.4 (b) Do you agree that ecological factors influenced the flow and ebb of the Harappan Civilization? Comment. [15 Marks]
Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023
The Harappan civilisation (HC) flourished from around 2800 -1900BC in Northwest and Western parts of India (Bronze Age)
Ecological factors affecting the HC
Flow - Significant role in emergence - Warm climatic conditions - improved survival rate of population - fertile soil - agriculture surplus achieved which is prerequisite for urbanisation - availability of rain - due to monsoon and rivers like Saraswati - Continuation (role of ecology) - helped in navigation increasing trade and commerce on inland Waterways
Ebb - reduction in fertility of soil - due to excess-cultivation and irrigation - affected food security - rainfall become erratic - droughts and floods common (Ex) Mohenjodaro flooded seven times as found by G F Dales - Monsoon link Theory (Ranojoy Adhikari) - The monsoon cycle affected resulting in drying up of rivers like Saraswati - Evidences - drought (Ex) in Kalibangan - aridity in Kalibangan [DP Chakrabarti, RK Sood] - rivers drying up [HT Lambrick]
Other factors affecting flow and ebb 1. Emergence of war-like tribes in Central Asia - affected safety of trade routes 2. Decline due to outbreak of malaria - study by KAR Kennedy 3. Earthquakes (or) evidence by RL Raikes at Mohenjodaro 4. Physiochemical explosion (or) fire at Kojdi, Surkotada [Dimitriev]
The Harappan civilisation's [?] is characterised by the decline of the urban centres due to combined effects of above mentioned factors and not Aryan invasion.