There is a need to resolve the ambiguity in the disqualification provisions under section 8 of RPA 1951. Discuss
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
Article 102 and 191 of the constitution deal with disqualification of MPs/MLAs from legislatures. Recently, ex-MP Rahul Gandhi was disqualified as MP on the basis of Section 8(3) of RPA 1951.
In this context:
Disqualification grounds
Constitutional: - unsound mind - undischarged insolvent - occupying office of profit, etc. - citizen of India (not) - etc.
Statutory (RPA 1951): - Section 8(1), 8(2): Disqualification if convicted under specific offences - Section 8(3): Automatic disqualification if convicted of with sentence more than 2 years - Section 123 - Section 135
Apparent ambiguity in section 8, RPA 1951 1. Section 8(1) and 8(2) provide for disqualification - if convicted of specific offences. 2. Section 8(3): automatic disqualification if sentence is greater than 2 years (for 6 years). 3. Ambiguity: Does section 8(3) over ride Section 8(1) and 8(2)?
Need to resolve the ambiguity 1. To uphold principle of transparency in electoral laws, so that voters may choose without bias 2. De-criminalisation of politics. 3. If section 8(3) does not override 8(1) and 8(2), it may give a loophole to criminal candidates 4. Similar such loophole was exploited by criminals - section 8(4), till it was struck down by SC in Lily Thomas case
Way forward 1. Clarify over-riding provision of section 8(3) 2. Further steps towards de-criminalisation of politics - robust implementation of Section 123 (Abhiram case) (bribery and soliciting votes on grounds of race, caste, religion, etc.)