Q.4 (a) The word 'Dhamma figures prominently in the Edicts of Asoka. Is he justified in calling them Dhamma-lipi? Elucidate. [15 Marks]
Abhijnan Hazarika, AIR 172, 2023
Ashokan Dhamma predominantly appears in edicts of Ashoka most particularly in 2nd and 7th pillar edict where he asks and answers about Dhamma.
Meaning of Dhamma as per edicts - Social rules of dos and donts - avoid stealing, being harsh to others - promote love and respect, tolerance towards others etc.
Justification in calling them Dhamma-lipi - Meant for the good of the people - ethical - moral conduct - Paternalistic attitude of Ashoka - expressed in the edicts - It is the crux of all religion (R S Tripathi) - positives of all combined and universal in its appeal - improved happiness and satisfaction among the people - peace and stability encouraged by promoting social harmony harmony in the empire - reflection of the Indian Dhamma - similarities with Upanishads - Chandogya Upanishad - (ex) non-violence - MRE 1- avoid killing of animals
Not justified as 1. Buddhism was spread in garb of Dhamma [of Emily Smart, DR Bhandarkar] 2. New religion was spread by Ashoka for his officials [JF Fleet] - as was very powerful 3. A tool to consolidate empire [Romila Thapar] - not for people's welfare 4. A Buddhist core is definitely reflected - excessive emphasis on Ahimsa - Bhabru minor rock edict mentions 6 Buddhist books as books on dhamma - RE8 mentions that he started pilgrimage after a visit to Kapilavastu
However, as Upinder Singh points out Ashoka was an innovator and the Dhamma cannot be equated with narrow sectarian beliefs, so can be classified as Dhamma-life to a some extent which improved the lives of the people of that ages.