Topper Copies

Assess the contribution of the accounts of the Chinese travellers as source of Ancient Indian History.

Vishnupriya, AIR 149, 2025

Chinese travellers came to the court of Mauryas, Guptas, Vardhanas informally & formally ; that act as a relevant source of information of those times.

1. Fa-Hien's accounts - Came to the court of Chandragupta Maurya - Details of king - palace attendants, luxurious lifestyle. - city of Pataliputra, trench to protect. - Trade of the city - occupational groups - cobblers, carpater etc. - Buddhist sites eg: Sarnath, Kaushambi, Lumbini - Peaceful society, no drinking - No strict punishments. (No capital punishments)

Problems - only idolised king, Buddhist compan son with china. - restricted to elite circle laguage barrier. - Complete peace - wrong - Presence of capital punishment, amputation etc, wars., meat eating etc

2. Xuan Zang - Visited the court of Harshavardhan of Kannauj - Idolised king, size of Army - 60,000 cavalry, 1000 elephants - Peace - loving king. - 84000 stupas built. - Prayagraj & Kannauj assembly by Harsha - Less focus on Polity. - Never lost any battle; captured whole India (exaggerated) - Indians - 2 instances of stealing - Rugged geography of India - society - areca nuts chewing people, barefoot, bathing rituals. - Visited Nalanda, Vikramshila, Odantapuri etc.

⇒ Limitations 1. Exaggerated size of army - 1000 elephant 2. Aihole inscription - defeat of Harsha by Pulakeshin II not mentioned 3. Idolised India in front of China 4. Restricted to royal court (elite) 5. Language barrier, wrote only after returning to China (memory problem)

3. I-Tsing - Gives details of Buddhist sites- Nalanda, Vikramshila etc. - No much about polity. - Instances of Thievery - Geography - not easy to follow- Ganga, Yamuna river systems. - Himalayan passes mentioned- Bolan pass,

Problems - didn't stay much in India - local interaction is less - Took secondary reference from Xuan Zang & FaHein - error probability

Thus, the Chinese accounts give clear picture of the society, polity, culture ; but also are biased, must be read with caution.