Kalhana's Rajatarangini is the best example of history writing tradition in early India. Discuss.
Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025
Kalhana's 'Rajatarangini' is the history of Kashmir from early years to 12century providing 'chronicles' of Kashmir life in 8 books. Rajatarangini -> Book I-III -> Gonanda Dynasty and Aditya Dynasty -> Books IV-VIII -> have better chronology Information of Karkota, Utpala & Lohara Dynasty.
Rajatarangini as Best Example of History writing in India - Kalhana mentions history writing should be done based on facts & reliable sources Used -> 1) History by 11 Chroniclers of Kashmir 2) Studies royal charters and inscription 3) Direct connection with polity -> Father under Lohara Dynasty - It should be based on scientific study & expertise Eg. avoided rhetorics and had no king's patronage - Should not have missing or incorrect information Eg. criticised Nripavali for it - Should be able to take reader to past & be distantic in nature
Features of Rajatarangini - Objective - dispassionate account of Kashmir polity - Chronology - was maintained, given linear account - Holistic - gave complete information of political genealogies, king's policies socio-economic life of people and impact of polity on people.
Criticism of Rajatarangini - Sanskrit - dependence on mainly Sanskrit texts show limited sources of study - Bias for Brahmanical values visible - Regionalism - Focus on Kashmir -> Maurya as Kashmir dynasty shows error - Gender Bias - excess criticism of Queen Didda - Exhaltation of Lalitaditya - bias - Chronology - issues due to [?] text -> one king has 300 years reign -
However, RC Majumdar appreciates Kalhana's Rajatarangini as significant & conscious effort towards history writing in modern times