Critically analyse whether the success of the Mughals is to be credited to their robust Jagirdari and Mansabdari system.
Vishnupriya, AIR 149, 2025
Mughals tried to control & consolidat their empire by centralising through the Jagirdari & mansabdari systems
Why success of Mughals can be credited to the mansabdari & jagirdari systems
1. Helped in creating a robust state-led military - mansab. 2. Uniform & stable bureaucracy - ranks were fixed in clear hierarchy 3. Led to stability in tax collection - Eg: Jagirdars were maintaining troops to collect revenue. 4. Led to check of abuse of power by the nobility - Eg: Jagirdars were frequently transferred 5. Led to better organisation of forces Eg: good quality & number of horses maintained 6. Introduced flexibility : Eg: Mashrut jagirs allowed sawar to be increased in case of internal security threat
Problem with this interpretation
1. still led to the agrarian revolts 2. Internal power rivalry among mansabs created rifts (eg) Corruption problems 3. Destitution & poverty of the peasants - due to high rents & revenue 4. Lack of commitment by jagirdars - as they anyway got transferred - no focus on increasing the quality of produce 5. less control by the sultan as area under mansabs increased 6. Could not control inflationary tendencies, did not boost trade further.
Thus, though the systems of Mansabdari & Jagirdari improved the success of Mughals, they had their limitations which eventually led to the decline of mughals