Was there any potentiality of emergence of capitalism in Mughal India along the lines of what happened in Europe? Discuss.
Sattwik Satyakam Devta, AIR 100, 2025
The [?] and 18th century are the formative periods of capitalism in Europe. During the same, Mughals ruled India. Capitalism has certain key elements which must be satisfied such as cheap labour, capital for investment, production for market, industries and thriving trade and commerce. Was there scope of Capitalism in India ?
1. Cheap labour was abundant. The caste system ensured labour availability as per skill needed 2. Capital was available as seen from the presence of rich men like Virji Vohra, who had enough means for investment 3. Market production: Urbanisation and trade promoted craft production in cotton, silk, metals, leather, etc 4. Trade and commerce also thrived due to presence of groups like Multanis, Baniyas, Chettis, etc
Constraints to Capitalism
1. Low levels of innovation in tools and implements - prohibited mass production 2. Lack of state support to naval trade like that in Europe 3. Independent artisans didn't work under 'factory' system, hence they produced as per capability 4. Consumption led economy - for ex. Mughal Karkhanas which produced for personal needs of nobles
While some potential for capitalism existed in Mughal India, there was no effort by the state to develop it. The consequent Industrial revolution in Europe decisively shifted the advantage of capitalism away from India.