Topper Copies

How far do you agree that the Mughal State was centralized State? Discuss.

Sattwik Satyakam Devta, AIR 100, 2025

Historians belonging to the 'Aligarh School' such as Irfan Habib, Athar Ali among others, have contended that the Mughal state was a centralized state.

Arguments in Support of Centralised State - The monetary system, with high level of standardisation based on silver rupayah, gold mohr, copper dam across the empire suggests centralised state - Irfan Habib considers "Zabt system" (method of revenue assessment based on measurement) as a sign of administrative uniformity - The bureaucratized nobility based on heirarchy on basis of mansabdari system has been cited as evidence of centralisation - J.F. Richards considers the flourishing trade and commerce - both intra-regional and international was possible because of centralised polity - Based on W.H. Moreland's study of Mughal agrarian system, historians argue that such uniformity in agrarian production was possible only in a centralised empire - The division of empire into revenue circles (dastur-ul-amals) as given in Ain-i-Akbari gives evidence of centralisation

But some recent works have challenged this traditional view of Mughal state as a centralised state.

Contrary Views - Historians have pointed out on excessive reliance on Ain-i-Akbari by Aligarh school - which contains only concise information - Muzaffar Alam and Sanjay Subramanian have shown that only few select regions were included in arazi (measured land) and not the entire empire - Arguments on centralised state mostly base on evidence from Akbar's reign (1556) to Aurangzeb's (1707) - Cheton Singh has argued that Mughal authority might have been centralised in doab area, but at periphery, it was weak - Stephen Blake considers Mughal state as a patrimonial bureaucratic state

Given the huge extent of the Mughal empire, there must have been varying degrees of centralising tendencies across the empire.