"The suspension of Non-Cooperation Movement was a national calamity". Critically examine.
Sattwik Satyakam Devta, AIR 100, 2025
The Non-Cooperation movement was abruptly revoked by Gandhiji owing to the rising instances of violence that peaked during the unfortunate Chauri Chaura incident.
Why suspension was a national calamity?
1. Sudden end of first organised Congress mass movement- - It was Congress's first experiment with mass action - Sudden withdrawal demoralised the Congress workers 2. Hindu-Muslim unity breached - The unity forged due to Khilafat movement died down - Revivalist groups like Hindu Mahasabha and Muslim League became stronger 3. Masses dissappointed - Masses which had participated first time in a national movement like peasant, worker were largely disappointed - At some places, the movement continued despite official withdrawal 4. Rise in revolutionary activities - Many youth leaders like Ram Prasad Bismil, Bhagat Singh, etc who had participated became disenchanted with the Congress - They took to individual acts of extremism 5. Failed to attain its objective of swaraj - The sudden withdrawal also broke the hopes of attaining swaraj within a year, which Gandhiji had proposed during beginning 6. The movement was at its peak - During its withdrawal, the movement attained highest momentum - eliciting huge participation of masses - It was also anticipated by many that British may give in to their demands - But the sudden withdrawl felt like stepback to the inspired Masses
But suspension was necessary
- It showed Gandhiji's non-compromising attitude to non-violence, which cannot be done away at any cost - The government would have justified heavy-handed repression on account of violence - It was difficult to maintain the mass movement for a longer time and some interim constructive work had to be done - Given the animosity of certain sections like Indian businesses, it might have divided Indian unity as well
The suspension of Non-cooperation movement though was sudden but the rise of 'mobocracy' left Gandhiji with no other option.