Topper Copies

"The Government of India Act of 1935 had all brakes, but no engine." Comment.

Sattwik Satyakam Devta, AIR 100, 2025

The Government of India Act of 1935 aimed to establish a federal government at Centre and responsible government at states. But its provisions made it unworkable from the beginning - "all brakes, but no engine".

Defects of Government of India Act, 1935

1. No federal government was formed - since princely states declined to join 2. Dyarchy at provinces - Ministers couldn't handle important matter like finance, home, law and order 3. Separate electorates resulted in communalisation of the electorate 4. A powerful centre was maintained as most subjects were included in the central list 5. Congress was dissatisfied as it didn't grant any real power to responsible governments 6. The electorate was very narrow - only about 10% of the population eligible to vote 7. Demands of self-government, greater Indian representation in Viceroy's executive council were ignored

Hence, the act of 1935 largely failed to take off due to its inherent defects.