Topper Copies

"The scheme of Dyarchy was 'cumbrous, complex, confused system, having no logical basis and rooted in compromise' and was foredoomed to failure." Explain.

Sattwik Satyakam Devta, AIR 100, 2025

The system of Dyarchy was introduced in the provincial governments under the Montagu-Chelmsford reforms of 1919.

Reasons of Failure

1. All important subjects like finance, law and order, police were kept under reserved list 2. Only non-crucial matters like agriculture, health, education, etc remained in transfered subject 3. Lack of finances - Meant that Indian ministers shouldered responsibility without any real power 4. Hence, ministers couldn't give effect to their initiatives 5. Even the bureaucracy, being only responsible to Viceroy, did not co-operate with Indian ministers 6. People were angry at ministers since they couldn't fulfill their expectations 7. There was constant tussle between the Viceroy's executive council and the decision of legislative council

Therefore, dyarchy system was doomed to fail.