Topper Copies

"If the prosperity and happiness of a nation be the criterion of wisdom and success, Lord Cornwallis's permanent settlement of 1793 is the wisest and most successful measure which the British nation had adopted in India". Critically examine this perspective of R.C. Dutt.

Sattwik Satyakam Devta, AIR 100, 2025

The statement by R.C. Dutt highlights the prevalent support of the moderate nationalists for the permanent settlement of 1793.

Permanent Settlement - The Good

1. Fixed revenues permanently - forever - hence no scope of corruption while collection 2. Zamindars could use growth in income to invest in agriculture and subsequent extension 3. Peasant rights would be safeguarded through written 'patta' 4. State would get regular revenue and fixed revenue 5. By promoting agricultural output in cotton and silk-trade will be promoted, which could be taxed

Permanent Settlement - Defects

1. The revenue fixed was very high - often couldn't be paid by peasants - led to eviction 2. Rules were violated on ground - no proper assessment, no patta system was carried out and illegal cesses (abwabs) continued 3. Customary rights of peasants ignored - hence were reduced to tenants-at-will 4. 'Sunset Laws' - led to dispossession of lands 5. Even the Government was dissatisfied as the revenue couldn't be increased

Hence, as Daniel Thorner has shown, the state itself became the supreme landlord, peasants suffered under heavy demand and it led to ruin of the peasantry.