Topper Copies

Do you think that the British conquered India "in a fit of absent minded-ness"? Critically discuss.

Sattwik Satyakam Devta, AIR 100, 2025

British historian Lord Seely has argued that British conquered India in a "fit of absentminded-ness" as there was no conscious policy to conquer India.

Yes - India was Conquered in a "fit of absent minded-ness"

1. PJ Marshall has argued there was no consistent policy for governing India by British until the 1784 Pitt's India Act 2. PJ Marshall and AG Hopkins argue that lack of communication, lack of knowledge about India in British official circles existed prior to 1784 3. Hence, it were the men on spot - the servants of East India Company and their 'sub-imperialism', which led to capture of India 4. It is only after the private traders made fortunes and returned to England as 'nabobs' that the government paid attention to the Indian 'territories' 5. Also, the need to secure trading operations and the need to establish peace and stable frontiers drove the English into a road of conquest 6. Therefore, it was the exigencies of trade and commerce, infighting among native rulers, which led to the acquisition of an empire

Counter-Views

1. On the other hand, many evidence point that British were not merely responding to the crisis but also creating opportunities to take on such conquest, as observed by Eugene Irschik 2. Policies of Governors-General Cornwallis and Wellesley were clearly geared towards acquiring more [?] territory under direct or indirect rule 3. Right from Battle of Plassey, English had consciously conspired to take indirect control of Bengal 4. The English interfered into local politics of Marathas, Carnatic, Hyderabad with the same aim 5. Parliament was aware of such activities as it renewed charter of the company, imposed annual payment of £400,000 from 1767 on its 'Indian territories'

Here, as observed by Shekhar Bandyopadhyay, India was not acquired by a fit of absent mindedness but rather at the cognisance of a very small number of people, without national awareness.