"It was in this almost unrecognizable form that the Ilbert Bill was finally enacted….it was primarily a failure of the Viceroy." Comment.
Sattwik Satyakam Devta, AIR 100, 2025
The Ilbert Bill was introduced in 1883 by law member CP Ilbert during tenure of Viceroy Lord Ripon.
Provisions of Ilbert Bill
1. It attempted to introduce parity between Indian judges and British judges in the mofussil towns 2. It allowed Indian judges to preside over civil and criminal cases concerning British persons
Response of British
1. Both official and non-official Britishers opposed the bill vehemently 2. Flawed arguments such as 'effeminacy', 'lack of integrity', 'lack of respect for women' of the Indians were blamed to deny them from judging an Englishman and women
Final Unrecognizable Form
- Finally, provisions of the bill were severely watered down - It provided a mix of European and Indian judges in matters involving Europeans
Failure of Viceroy
- Despite liberal and reformist zeal of Lord Ripon, he buckled under Conservative pressure - After progressive steps like local self-government, amendment to arms act, etc, this measure was considered a stepback
Hence, it was primarily failure of the viceroy who succumed to the white pressure.