Topper Copies

Examine the various views regarding the role of iron technology in ushering Second Urbanisation in Ancient India. [15 Marks]

Samiksha Dwivedi, AIR 56, 2025

The debate of significance of iron technology in 600 BC leading to second urbanisation was initiated by DD Kosambi

Perspective of DD Kosambi & RS Sharma. 1. Supported iron technology allowed deforestation (clearing forest tracts) -> availabilty of fertile land for cultivation 2. Alluvial plains allowed agricultural surplus and supported increase in population 3. Rise of non- agricultural workforce like ruling class, artisans and craftsmen and traders. Seeked to gain access to surplus by exchange or territorial control 4. Established political centres like Rajgarhe, Trade centres like Sravasti and Avanti 5. Supported V Gordon Childe's theory of urbanisation by innovation

Opposed by A Ghosh and Mihar ranjan Ray 1. The forest clearance by burning the forest not iron tools 2. Iron use not at initiation of urbanisation but helped in sustaining during middle phase 3. Emphasised importance of sociopolitical factors in urbanisation Political consolidation and social organisation supported urbanisation, even if iron did not initiate, it helped in sustaining it .

Makhan Lal 1. Did not find any increase in use of iron in 600 - 200 BC (substantially) 2. Largescale deforestation was not feature of India till British rule

Rajan Gurukkul 1. Iron by itself doesnot lead to urbanisation 2. The iron technology with South India were rural and could not urbanised due to conflicts & tribal warfare

Dhavalikar Provides different perspective by connecting environment change and favourable climate for urbanisation in Ganga Plain.

It is generally accepted iron technology and supported military supremacy initially and complemented socio-economic & political transformation for urbanisation.