Topper Copies

Critically examine the notion of the Mauryan state being a highly centralized system.

Sattwik Satyakam Devta, AIR 100, 2025

In Nationalist historiography, the Mauryan state has been presented as a centralised state having overarching control over its people.

Maurya State as a Centralised State - Verses from the Arthashastra have been cited to support this claim - Arthashastra talks about the all powerful king who exercised absolute control through an elaborate administrative machinery - High ranking officials like amatyas (ministers), adhyakshas (head of departments), samahartri (chief accountant), samnidhatri (chief treasurer) assisted the king - Arthasashtra talks about state-owned land where farmers and labourers were hired to work and state-owned enterprises like armouries, chariot-building, ship-building, stone-working, etc - Elaborate wage control measures and even specific wages for both state-owned enterprises and private enterprises are mentioned - Princes were appointed as Governors (Uparika) of the provinces to maintain the centralised structure - Spies like pativedakas and pulisani dispersed throughout the empire to inform king about seditious activities - Finding of Ashokan and other Mauryan inscriptions across the empire also gives evidence of the centralised control - Romila Thapar has recently changed her initial opinion of Maurya empire being centralised and now proposes it was consisted of (1) a metropolitan area (immediate area around Magadha) (2) Core area (areas of state formation) (3) Peripheral areas (areas not undergoing transformation to state)

Recent Studies - Gerrard Fussman has rejected above arguments and insists Maurya rule was superimposed above existing states - In the absence of communication systems, some amount of local autonomy is inevitable - The kind of control envisaged in Arthashastra is difficult even in modern nation-states - Ashokan inscriptions across regions show minor differences – in terms of language, expressions, etc which show autonomy in local initiative - Upinder Singh argues that interpretation of Mauryan empire as centralised state is largely based on an uncritical reading of the Arthashastra

Given the huge empire that covered almost entire India and also north-western regions, the nature of control must have varied across time and space in the Mauryan empire.